Top of Form

Bottom of Form

 

Mental Health Notes

by Daniel Shaw, LCSW


July 2007

The Joy of Imperfection

It's summertime – is the living easy yet?  Stress all gone?  Not yet?  Not surprising.  As the Buddhists say (pardon my paraphrase):  if you're born a human, then you've got stress – no exceptions.  Luckily, many folks manage life's normal level of stressful ups and downs with some measure of acceptance. There is a particular kind of stress, though, which many people experience, that can be subtle and which often goes unidentified:  the stress of having to be Perfect.  That's Perfect with a capital P.

We can all be a bit perfectionistic at times, but "capital P" Perfectionists are more extreme.  It's not just that they are unduly frustrated by flaws, weaknesses, vulnerabilities, and - heaven forbid - mistakes.  It's that good isn't good enough, great isn't good enough, and even excellent isn't good enough.  Nothing is good enough, and someone always has to be blamed for that. 


Perfectionists have a rigid expectation of their own Perfection, and a tendency to devalue their own achievements, no matter how considerable.  They alternate between being judgmental of others, and of themselves.  For the Perfectionist, being "good enough" is a cop-out, a lazy person's excuse for not trying hard enough.  The result of this attitude is not greater productivity:  it's exhaustion.  Like Sisyphus, they feel like they're always pushing a boulder up a hill – or they make the people around them feel that way. 


Perfectionists can't stop judging, and it is always the same verdict:  "Guilty of not being good enough."  In my view, unless you're being paid to be a judge, or unless you're a criminal, then you should not be living in a courtroom, where someone is always being accused, put on trial, condemned, sentenced and punished.  Contrary to the Perfectionist's beliefs, conscious or unconscious, imperfection is not a crime, and neither is it a sin.


For some who drink or drug too much, their substance abuse can be a way of shutting up the accusatory voice of their inner slave driver - the inner task master that never stops judging.  Their drug of choice provides some relief, but only temporarily, of course, and at much too great a cost.            


I once worked with a gifted and intelligent man, whose life seemed charmed to those who knew him socially, but who was grinding himself down with his relentless self-criticism.  I asked him, even though I knew what his answer would be, "What if you won the Nobel Prize?  Then would you be good enough?"  We both agreed that, Nobel in hand, he'd still find a way to trash himself.  I am pretty convinced that, in spite of our imperfections, we all have the right to feel that we are basically good enough – to live, to love and be loved.  I hope he came to feel that way, too.


So it's summer.  Time to bask in the joy of imperfection.  If you're having a summer vacation this year, see if you can make it a break from the constant stress of Perfectionism.  Appreciating and enjoying what is good enough, in one's self and in others, while knowing that nothing is ever Perfect, is actually a vacation from stress that you can take any time, any place.                      


© Daniel Shaw 2007

 

dan@danielshawlcsw.com
http://www.danielshawlcsw.com

 

 

http://www.mynewsletterbuilder.com/tools/open.php?send_id=null